John Kirkham Law
  • Home
  • Why Update
  • John
  • Residential / Mixed-Use
  • Commercial
  • Reviews
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Request Proposal

SB 323: the butterfly effect, with lawyers

5/16/2023

 
Senate Bill 323 revised Civil Code section 5145(a) to provide that, "[i]f a member establishes ... that [association election law was] not followed, a court shall void any results of the election unless the association establishes ... that the association’s noncompliance ... did not affect the results of the election."

"Did not affect the results of the election" is ambiguous. First, what are "the results of the election?" Since Civil Code section 5145 controls all causes of action in regards to Article 4 (Civil Code
§§ 5100-5145), "the results of the election" encompasses each and every right afforded under Article 4. For example, if a member's free speech or inspection rights are violated, arguably such illegality affected "the results of the election" even if it had no effect on the proposition put to the members.

Read More

SB 323: the chicken or egg of compliance

2/13/2023

 
Senate Bill 323 amended Civil Code section 5105 to provide that election rules must contain a laundry-list of mandatory new provisions. As discussed in my other blog posts, however, many of these provisions will conflict with most communities' existing governing documents.

Civil Code section 4205 currently controls conflicts between the law and governing documents and between governing documents themselves. "To the extent of any conflict," the Section provides that the law prevails, then CC&Rs, then articles, then bylaws, with operating rules - including election rules - at the bottom of the pile.


Read More

SB 323: kicking small associations when they're down

12/12/2022

 
Senate Bill 323 continues Civil Code section 5100(f), which provides that "[d]irectors shall not be required to be elected pursuant to this article if the governing documents provide that one member from each separate interest is a director." 

Section 5100(f)'s reference to "this article" is to the 2006 Election Law, Civil Code sections 5100-5145, which of course includes the bulk of SB 323.

Read More

SB 323: fiduciaries not fiduciary-ing

9/5/2022

 
Senate Bill 323 revised Civil Code section 5145(a) to provide that “[a] member of an association may [sue] for a violation of this article by the association … within one year of the date that the inspector notifies the board and membership of the election results or the cause of action accrues, whichever is later.”

Civil Code section 5120(b), however, currently provides that boards are responsible for notifying the membership of election results. If an inspector does so, this in and of itself could arguably constitute an election law violation.

Read More

SB 323: making associations great again

6/14/2022

 
Senate Bill 323 added new Civil Code section 5105(c)(4), which provides that an association may disqualify a candidate for the board “if that person discloses, or if the association is aware or becomes aware of, a past criminal conviction that would, if the person was elected, either prevent the association from purchasing the fidelity bond coverage required by [Civil Code s]ection 5806 or terminate the association’s existing fidelity bond coverage.”

This optional qualification raises a number of questions and problems, both for associations which adopt it and those which do not:

Read More
<<Previous
Forward>>
    2025 HOA Law Blog

    A thrilling blog that isn't legal advice about California HOA law but might be a vehicle to vent. Reposts and reprints with attribution.

    Topics:
    ​

    All
    Assembly Bill 3182
    Assembly Bill 502
    Assembly Bill 670
    Senate Bill 222
    Senate Bill 234
    Senate Bill 323
    Senate Bill 392
    Senate Bill 432
    Senate Bill 754

John Kirkham Law

Common interest expertise.

Current, comprehensive, carefully-tailored HOA governing documents.

Cost-effective fees.
Disclaimer

​I created this site for informational and advertising purposes. It is not intended to serve as and should not be relied on for legal advice. No attorney-client relationship exists until I am retained pursuant to the terms of my fee agreement.
​Copyright 2025 John Kirkham. All rights reserved.
  • Home
  • Why Update
  • John
  • Residential / Mixed-Use
  • Commercial
  • Reviews
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Request Proposal